Home Insurance Coverage Refused due to Home Exchange

We have been enthusiastic members of Home Exchange for almost three years and have participated in 17 exchanges. When we were preparing to join Home Exchange, we checked with our insurance company to ensure that we would be covered when our home was occupied by exchange participants. The one condition the company insisted on was for us to inform them when an exchange was occurring and how many people would be involved. This has worked well for the last 2 1/2 years and then, suddenly without any forewarning, when we called the company about our latest exchange, we were told that the underwriters would no longer provide insurance to us if we continued with Home Exchange participants staying in our home.

I reminded the call-center worker of the features of Home Exchange. At first she insisted that the decision was final, but I insisted on talking to a supervisor about our situation. I spoke with the supervisor and it sounded like I might have gotten through to him. However, he said they would discuss it further with the underwriters and call us back in a few days.

When they called us back, they informed us that our insurance policy would be terminated if we continued with Home Exchange.

I was never given the opportunity to talk to any of the underwriter representatives. The call center workers implied that if it had been Air B’n’B, they would have covered us. Alternatively, they also said they would have covered a secondary residence. I’m not one hundred percent if this was an accurate understanding on my part because the workers’ accents were difficult to understand at times. I am currently trying to discover a better way to communicate with our insurance company.

Currently, we are continuing our membership, but we have temporarily changed our calendar to zero availability. We do have exchange points that we can use. We really like Home Exchange and wish to continue.

We have two questions resulting from this:

  1. Has anyone else experienced this issue and if so, how did you deal with it?
  2. What insurance companies are willing to accept Home Exchange?

Hello. You don’t say in which country or state ? Insurances are not the same at all from a country to another

hat I understood it had nothing to do with

Sorry about that reply. I was having trouble with the posting format. We’re from Nova Scotia Canada. My understanding of what the company told me was that it was the underwriters who decided to change our coverage and nothing to do with any government regulations.

Thank you for sharing your experience with us. It’s lovely to hear that you’ve enjoyed 17 exchanges over the past three years, and we’re sorry to hear that you’ve encountered this unexpected difficulty with your home insurance.

We understand how frustrating and worrying this must be, particularly when you’ve been exchanging successfully for so long and have always made a point of informing your insurer about your exchanges.

Although HomeExchange is based on the principle of reciprocal hospitality rather than paid accommodation, insurance providers each have their own terms and conditions when it comes to having guests staying in your home. Unfortunately, some insurers may have specific restrictions or interpretations that affect home exchanges, even when no money is changing hands.

Our advice would be to ask your insurer for written clarification of exactly why they consider HomeExchange exchanges incompatible with your policy. It may also be worth asking whether they have a specific policy or alternative cover that would accommodate non-commercial home exchanges.

Etienne has asked which country you are from, I assume so that others from your country may be able to offer advice. In our experience it really does vary from country to country - not because of any government policies, but rather that home insurance varies a lot around the world. If you let us know which country you’re based in, other members may be able to share more relevant recommendations and experiences.

This is also a topic that has come up before on this forum, so I also suggest you do a search for “insurance” and you’ll find other similar posts with comments giving advice.

We really hope you’re able to find a solution that allows you to continue enjoying HomeExchange!

Melissa