✅ Did you know? A green calendar doesn't mean an automatic yes!

Hello everyone!

Today I just wanted to give you a quick reminder about the calendar, especially for newbies who don’t have much experience with HomeExchange and home exchanging yet.

When you’re new to home exchange, you sometimes tend to think that staying with a home exchange is like looking for a rental: you look at the dates in the person’s calendar, they’re available, so you assume that your request will be accepted automatically.

But that’s not actually how it works on HomeExchange!
Each HomeExchange member remains free to decide whether or not they would like to host another member.

Why?
When renting, you pay for a service. With HomeExchange, we rely on the hospitality of another member, who shares their home for free financially (and trusts us to take care of it).

A member who refuses our exchange proposal when their calendar is available may do so for a variety of reasons, some of them could be pragmatic (his or her dates are not available after all, he or she is already finalizing an exchange with another member, etc.).

But as home exchange is based above all on human experiences, a member who refuses your exchange request may also do so for more subjective reasons: he or she may find your message too brief, too direct, not enough of this, or too much of that so that they don’t get the right feeling. It may also happen that, again for subjective reasons, they don’t feel comfortable with your profile (perhaps they don’t find it complete enough, or are suspicious of the lack of comments on your profile, etc.). It happens, and it’s perfectly human (we all have certain criteria for welcoming members into our homes - and it’s our right).

So that’s why it’s usually necessary to contact several members before getting the famous “yes” to our exchange proposals. Because each member has their own criteria, their own feelings, their own needs. So let’s respect that, and avoid taking rejections personally 😊 Let’s put our sensitivities aside, rejections are part of the home exchange game.

That said, here’s some advice when sending exchange requests and completing your profile: avoid telegraphic messages, try to personalize your messages, introduce yourself, and why you’d like to stay at that member’s home. It’s all this that makes the “yes” you’re looking for, and the stay itself, so magical - because it all started with a simple message to a person you didn’t know at the outset.

Our team is here for you!
If you’re just starting out, or if you’re having trouble finding an exchange, don’t forget that HomeExchange is here to help you: you can contact our super ambassadors on the online chat, or get in touch with our member support team. And, of course, ask all the questions you want in this (wonderful) group!

4 Likes

Yes it’s very true. We have only hosted three times totaling nine days but have yet to find a Home exchange for when we are traveling. I just found the forums so I will be doing some reading here then maybe we will post about our next trip and see if it works better than contacting someone out of the blue. I hope to figure out how to exchange as the concept has always been very interesting to me. :crossed_fingers:

2 Likes

Oh no I’m sorry to hear that you’re having trouble using your points !

Some tricks that I like to use are to use the filter “GuestPoint exchange” to find people specifically looking to host for GuestPoints and to filter for secondary homes as there’s a higher chance that it’ll be available :wink:

1 Like

Thank you for the tips! I will definitely try

1 Like

It might be the area you are trying to go??? I tried everything but a singing telegram and could get NO one to say yes to us in Amsterdam, even in the off season. I’ve had great success in the US. Tried Toronto area in January. 4 tries, 1 lovely no with brief explanation, 3 rounds of crickets for the others. I will keep trying and I hope you will too.

I consider that a green or orange calendar entry simply means that a host is open to considering proposals. It is not like an airbnb or a hotel calendar where “available” means a certainty that a booking request will be accepted. Especially for a reciprocal exchange, the host may or may not want to go to your home. It’s nothing personal, but your home may simply not have the amenities, or be in the location that the host is looking for. We are retired and love to travel, so our calendar is “green” for most of the year. However, there are specific places where we want to travel, and we will politely decline requests from places where we do not want to travel.

For a host whose calendar is blue (home is available for Guest Points), the chance of being accepted is better because the host does not have to decide whether or not they want to go to your home. However, they may still have other reasons for declining that are not personal… perhaps the requestor is a new member and the host prefers to accommodate only members with a record of previous exchanges and reviews, or perhaps before accepting, the host wants to research whether they can use the guest points from your visit and use them to stay somewhere else, but their research shows that there are no available homes at the places where they want to go.

I agree with a previous responder that your best chances for acceptance are for a guest point visit at a host’s secondary residence. If they are being honest and up-to-date with their calendar, then there aren’t very many reasonable justifications for non-approval unless there is something questionable in your past reviews or they are holding the place open temporarily for a previous requestor to finalize.

The guest point system is a great feature of home exchange… it widens tremendously the number of available homes for members to consider. I know that some members have a preference for only reciprocal exchanges, but we very much appreciate and use the guestpoint system.